Comparing The Best AI Tools for Instagram Auto-Replies (Comments & DMs)
- Let's Compare AI
- Dec 27, 2025
- 5 min read
If you’re getting more Instagram comments and DMs than you can keep up with, you’re not alone.
Auto-replies can help you:
Respond instantly to comments
Send links or offers via DM
Answer common questions
Turn engagement into leads or sales — without being glued to your phone
In this guide, you’ll find four of the best AI tools for Instagram auto-replies, each suited to a different type of user. I’ll walk you through what each tool does best, pricing, real-world feedback, and an overall score out of 100 so you can quickly decide what’s right for you.
1. ManyChat — Best all-rounder for Instagram automation
⭐Score: 90/100
If your goal is to turn Instagram engagement into leads, signups, or sales, ManyChat is hard to beat.
You can automatically:
Reply when someone comments on a post or Reel
Trigger a DM when a comment includes a keyword
Guide people through structured DM flows (links, questions, follow-ups)
ManyChat really shines if you run campaigns like:
“Comment GUIDE and I’ll DM you the link.”
Pricing
Free plan available
Pro plans start around $15/month, but pricing increases as your contacts grow
What people on the web say
G2 reviewers often highlight how much time it saves and how intuitive the flow builder is
Common criticism: pricing scales quickly as your audience grows
You’ll like ManyChat if…
You’re a creator, coach, or small business
You want proven comment-to-DM funnels
You care more about marketing automation than “human-like” AI chat
2. Jotform Instagram Agent — Best for AI-style replies & stories
⭐Score: 82/100
If you want something that feels more like an AI assistant than a traditional chatbot, Jotform’s Instagram Agent is interesting.
Instead of rigid flows, it focuses on:
AI-generated replies
Handling DMs, comments, and story mentions
Responding using your brand tone and knowledge base
This makes it especially useful if people frequently reply to your Stories or ask similar questions repeatedly.
Pricing
You can get started for free
Paid Jotform plans start around $34/month (billed annually), with AI usage limits by plan
What people on the web say
Reviews mention it’s helpful for basic questions and automations
Some users report mixed experiences with AI accuracy and tracking
You’ll like Jotform Instagram Agent if…
You want AI-style responses, not just keyword triggers
You get lots of Story replies or mentions
You already use (or are open to using) Jotform’s ecosystem
3. ReplyRush — Best simple option for creators
⭐Score: 75/100
ReplyRush is for you if you want something simple, fast, and Instagram-only.
It focuses on:
Turning comments into DMs automatically
Sending links or short messages via DM
Minimal setup and fewer features to manage
It doesn’t try to be an all-in-one marketing platform — and that’s exactly the appeal for many creators.
Pricing
Free plan available
Paid plans typically start around $10/month, with higher tiers for more usage
What people on the web say
There are currently very few third-party reviews (no major review volume yet)
App listings indicate it’s still building its user review base
You’ll like ReplyRush if…
You’re a creator or influencer
You mainly want comment-to-DM automation
You prefer simplicity over advanced workflows or AI
4. Respond.io — Best for teams & high-volume messaging
Score: 88/100
Respond.io is less about “Instagram hacks” and more about serious message management.
You get:
A shared inbox for Instagram (and other channels)
Workflow automation and routing
AI assistance for replies
Team collaboration and analytics
If multiple people manage your Instagram DMs — or if Instagram is just one of many channels you use — Respond.io makes things much easier to manage at scale.
Pricing
Starter plans from around $79/month
Higher tiers for advanced automation and larger teams
What people on the web say
Very strong review presence on G2
Frequently praised for support quality, reliability, and workflow flexibility
Main downside: price compared to creator-focused tool.
You’ll like Respond.io if…
You run a business or team
You handle a high volume of messages
You want structure, reporting, and collaboration
5. Tidio — Best multichannel option for growing businesses
⭐ Score: 88/100
Tidio is a strong choice if you want Instagram auto-replies as part of a wider multichannel messaging setup, rather than a tool built only for Instagram automation. Think of it as an all-in-one auto reply tool if you have multiple social media channels.
It focuses on:
Automating Instagram DMs using chatbot flows
Managing conversations across Instagram, website chat, Messenger, and more
Combining AI chatbots with live chat in a single inbox
Tidio isn’t designed purely for Instagram growth funnels, but it excels if you want one platform to manage conversations across multiple channels.
Pricing
Free plan available (limited automation)
Paid plans start around $29/month, depending on features and usage
What people on the web say
Reviews frequently praise Tidio’s ease of setup and clean interface
Users like having Instagram and website chat in one inbox
Some note Instagram automation is less specialised than Instagram-first tools
You’ll like Tidio if…
You run a business or brand, not just a creator account
You want Instagram auto-replies plus website chat and Messenger
You prefer an all-in-one messaging platform over multiple tools
Quick Comparison
⭐90/100
💲Pricing: Free plan available, Pro from ~$15/month
Best for: Comment-to-DM funnels, lead magnets, creators & small businesses
Auto-replies: Instagram comments + DMs
What users say: Easy to set up and powerful, but pricing can scale quickly
⭐82/100
💲Pricing: Free start, paid Jotform plans from ~$34/month (annual)
Best for: AI-style replies, story mentions & brand-aware responses
Auto-replies: DMs, comments, story mentions
What users say: Helpful for simple questions, mixed feedback on consistency
⭐75/100
💲Pricing: Free plan, paid plans from ~$10/month
Best for: Creators who want fast, simple comment-to-DM automation
Auto-replies: Comments → DMs
What users say: Very easy to use, but limited independent reviews so far
⭐88/100
💲Pricing: From ~$79/month
Best for: Teams, high message volume, shared inbox workflows
Auto-replies: Workflow-based comment & DM automation
What users say: Excellent support and reliability, higher price point
⭐ 88/100
💲 Pricing: Free plan available, paid plans from ~$29/month
Best for: Businesses wanting Instagram auto-replies as part of a multichannel inbox
Auto-replies: Instagram DMs + chatbot flows (with multichannel support)
What users say: Easy to set up, clean interface, and strong all-in-one messaging — less Instagram-specific than creator-only tools
Final recommendations
Choose ManyChat if you want the best overall tool for Instagram comment-to-DM marketing.
Choose Jotform Instagram Agent if you want more AI-driven replies and strong Story automation.
Choose ReplyRush if you’re a creator who wants fast, simple automation without complexity.
Choose Respond.io if you manage Instagram messages as part of a team or larger operation.
Choose Tidio if you want Instagram auto-replies plus website chat and other messaging channels managed from one simple inbox.
Comments